高级检索

    线性生产建设项目生态效益动态评价及其指标权重分析——以西安—商洛高速为例

    Dynamic evaluation of ecological benefits and weight analysis of indexes for the linear production and construction project: A case study of national highway from Xi'an to Shangluo

    • 摘要: 高速公路的网络化、规模化发展,导致严重的水土流失,同时高速公路的水土流失防治投入也十分巨大,科学评价高速公路等线性生产建设项目水土保持的生态效益可以为生产建设类项目水土保持评价提供科学依据。笔者以国家高速公路G40西安—商洛段为例,运用主成分分析法、层次分析法和极优模型计算相关指标的权重和隶属度值,以此为基础计算典型线型建设项目在施工前期、植被恢复期和建成使用期不同功能生态效益指数,分析线性生产建设项目水土保持的生态效益。结果显示:在施工前期径流模数综合得分最高;在植被恢复期土壤侵蚀模数综合得分最高;在建成使用期排水量与外排水含沙量综合得分最高。在施工前期,中低地区(秦岭以北)和阶地区(秦岭以南)的生态效益指数值分别为0.455和0.487,属于中等分类,说明该地区生态系统趋于稳定。在植被恢复期,比较各分区的值,发现秦岭以南都略小于秦岭以北,说明秦岭以北生态系统较为脆弱。在建成使用期,线性生产建设项目在不同区段的破坏程度不同,采取相应的水土保持措施后生态效益指数也是不同程度的增长,以秦岭以北主线工程区为例,生态效益指数由生产前期的0.455提高到建成使用期的0.578,这说明在采取水土保持措施之后,取得了一定的生态效益。在各个时期,主线工程区比其他区的生态效益指数值基本上都大,说明主线工程区的防治效果明显好于其他区。

       

      Abstract:
      Background The networking and large-scale development of highway have caused the serious soil erosion, naturally the investment for the control of soil and water loss in highway construction is huge. Therefore, scientific evaluation of ecological benefits from soil and water conservation in highway construction projects would provide the basis for the assessments of soil and water conservation in production and construction projects.
      Methods Evaluation indexes were firstly determined and scaled using the dispersion range model, then principal component analysis was used to obtain the comprehensive score of each evaluation index, further the analytic hierarchy process was further applied to calculate the weight of the evaluation indexes, and finally the ecological benefits were calculated by multiplying scaled evaluation indexes and their weights. The ecological benefits of different functional zones during pre-construction period, vegetation restoration period, and use period after highway built-up were all evaluated for national highway project G40 from Xi'an to Shangluo.
      Results 1) The runoff modulus index had the highest comprehensive score in the pre-construction period, with the soil erosion modulus index in the vegetation restoration period, and the displacement index and sediment concentration of discharged drainage index in the use period after highway built-up. 2) The ecological benefits in northern Qinling Mountains areas and southern Qinling Mountains areas were 0.455 and 0.487 respectively in the pre-construction period, indicating that the ecological system approached stable during this period.3) The ecological benefits in the northern Qinling Mountains areas were all smaller than those in southern Qinling Mountains areas in the vegetation restoration period, indicating that the ecological system in the northern Qinling Mountains areas was more vulnerable. 4) The ecological benefits of different functional zones during the use period after highway built-up were generally higher than those in the pre-construction period, such as the ecological benefit of mainline project area during the pre-construction period was 0.455 and it increased to 0.578 during the use period after highway built-up, and the ecological benefits of mainline project areas were always higher than other functional zones.
      Conclusions The ecological benefits of different functional zones in the national highway from Xi'an to Shangluo were calculated, and the results showed the soil and water conservation measures taken by the project, especially the mainline project area, have resulted in obvious ecological benefits.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回